Does it? Scully has came through the youth ranks and been POTY for Dunfermline for the past two years. I'd far rather he got a chance over a more experienced (and, yes, more expensive) cast-off from the lower leagues in England, as would probably be the most likely alternative. And it really isn't that big a step up for a goalkeeper - Scott Bain is now in the Scotland squad and was playing for Alloa last season. If we want to be a club that has a focus on youth development then guys like Scully need to play - he can't have done any more to deserve his shot.